(Siddhartha Kumar)
Source: timesofindia.indiatimes.com
IITs to treat disabled on par with SCs
17 Aug 2008, 0515 hrs IST, D Suresh Kumar,TNN
CHENNAI: The Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) must henceforth
treat physically disabled candidates at par with those from the
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
Consequently, physically disabled candidates for whom 3 % of seats
have been reserved in the IITs will be entitled for 40% relaxation in
marks that is currently extended to SC and ST candidates.
This follows an order delivered by the court of the chief commissioner
for persons with disabilities, New Delhi, on August 8 after parents of
two physically challenged candidates hailing from Chennai and Thane,
in separate petitions, pointed out that the IITs had treated their
children on a par with OBCs, which is in violation of a Supreme Court
ruling.
The court has said that the IITs must admit physically disabled
candidates who have a cut-off score of 104 and above in the current
academic session itself.
The chief commissioner for persons with disabilities Dr Manoj Kumar,
who is a quasi judicial authority, has directed the union ministry of
human resources development “to extend relaxation in marks and other
concession at par with SC/STs to all persons with disabilities,
irrespective of their vertical categories from the current academic
session.”
This year, the IITs had fixed a cut-off of 155 marks in the Joint
Entrance Examination for physically disabled candidates, which was
similar to that for the OBC applicants.
“As a result of this high cut-off only 20 of the 210 seats reserved
for the physically challenged were filled up in all the IITs,” said
Chennai-based M K Maheshwari, father of Rachit Maheshwari, a
physically disabled boy. “The remaining seats have fallen vacant and
nobody talks about it, while there is such a hue and cry over the
non-filling of OBC, SC and ST seats,” he lamented.
Maheshwari’s counsel argued “The common merit list of top 7903
candidates practically does not have any candidate with disability and
therefore fixing the aggregate cut off on the basis of the marks
scored by the last candidate in the common merit lists amounts to
fixing unrealistic targets for the physically disabled.”
Representatives of the union HRD ministry and the IIT Roorkee contested this.
The court pointed out that compared to other marginalised groups,
persons with disabilities, especially visually and hearing impaired,
are at a disadvantageous position “because the education system in the
country leaves a lot of be desired in terms of availability of
suitable teaching and learning material, trained teachers, appropriate
interfaces for conduction of examination and appropriate evaluation
methodology. The situation is all the more difficult in professional
and technical course.”
Referring to the contention of the IITs that physically disabled
candidates enjoyed the same reservation as entitled for their
community in vertical categories, Manoj Kumar said “while persons with
disabilities belong to SC/ST categories get relaxation of 40% marks,
the same benefit is not extended to physically disabled candidates
belonging to the open and OBC categories. This is discriminatory and
denies them equal opportunity to compete on equal footing with the
candidates with disabilities belonging to other vertical categories as
against the endorsement of the supreme court.”
Noting that relaxation in marks at par with SC/ST candidates was
extended to all persons with disabilities in the All India Engineering
Entrance Examination since 2007, the Delhi University and the Jamia
Millia University, he said that “it would be desirable that the
benefit of preparatory course extended to SC/ST candidates at the IITs
is also extended to students with disabilities. “
The court also directed the IITs “to declare vertical category wise
merit list for persons with disabilities i.e. SC-PH, ST-PH, OBC-PH and
Gen-PH from the next academic session.”
The IITs have also been directed to submit an action taken report
within 60 days of the receipt of the order.















